Windows Vista has been out for a few months now and I think it’s time to tackle whether it is worth it or not to upgrade. While Microsoft would love everyone to upgrade to Vista that will hardly happen. Unfortunately, all the OEM computers (HP-Compaq, Toshiba, Sony, etc.) are shipping their computers with Vista pre-installed, therefore giving the consumer no choice. The only OEM that does give you a choice (though however small) is Dell. If you purchase certain laptops or PC’s (usually the cheap and less powerful) from Dell you can choose Windows XP or Vista.
I have been thinking about switching to Vista for months myself but decided to wait until I could see how it performs on a PC/laptop built for Vista. Well the time has come.
A friend of mine, that just returned to Canada, needed to buy a laptop to communicate with his parents in South America. I offered my services to help him choose his laptop. He was under a budget which pretty much left no option for a MacBook so we had to look at some budget laptops.
So we had HP-Compaq, Toshiba, Acer and Gateway to choose from at the retailer we were at. Immediately we ruled out HP-Compaq as they like to install a lot of un-needed software. We also ruled out Toshiba because they can’t seem to build a computer with a good cooling system. We eventually ruled out Gateway because they just looked cheaply built. Acer was all we had left.
You’ll remember that I bought an Acer a while back and reviewed it on this website. It had been a very good laptop. One thing that really stands out is the screen quality. It has great contrast and colour. The downside was that at the time a $699 laptop came with a Celeron-M instead of a Core Duo or AMD Turion processor. All I can say is that sometimes that laptop is not a pleasure to play World of Warcraft on, but that’s not what I bought it for.
Anyways, we hooked ourselves up with a Turion X2 at 1.8GHz, 1GB DDR2 RAM, 120GB hard drive, ATI graphics and the normal bells and whistles that come with those computers (integrated microphone – a major plus for a laptop, bluetooth, and wireless-G card). Oh, and of course, it had Vista on it.
I was actually excited to see what Microsoft had done with the Operating System and was keeping my mind clear of negative thoughts.
As soon as we got it home we opened it up. OK, one of the things you sacrifice when buying an Acer is that you don’t get backup CDs. They actually make you burn your own. Unfortunately, the program that was supposed to do that kept locking up when we started the laptop up. In fact we had to disable it from startup. Whether that was due to Vista or not was not a question. That was just a sign of poorly written software.
So that finished and we had to install Windows updates. Man that was annoying and it wasn’t the updates that were annoying, it was the Wi-Fi software Vista comes with. Vista will not automatically connect to a Wi-Fi source. That is extremely annoying. Every time I wanted to connect to my wireless connection I had to go down to the task bar (or whatever it’s called now) and click connect.
Once past that we were able to download the updates. About ten restarts later we were back in business. We then immediately proceeded to uninstall Norton and install AVG Free. AVG works great under Vista and takes far less resources than Norton.
I was then curious to see what kind of resources we were using. I was surprised to see that both processor cores were working about 5 to 7% all the time. Oh and the RAM usage. That was crazy. We were looking at 750MB of RAM used (or memory as Windows memory manager isn’t that specific). That is nuts considering I can keep my laptop below 180MB at all times.
One thing I can say is that that laptop has great battery life with those Turion processors. We installed World of Warcraft and were playing it and forgot to plug it in. The thing played flawlessly (and I mean with out any frame-skipping – which is unusual for World of Warcraft) until it just shut-off three hours later.
We did have a problem a couple days ago when we tried to update World of Warcraft on his computer. It would not patch. In fact it would not even load World of Warcraft. This error is Vista related.
Another thing I noticed with Vista is that Microsoft made everything needlessly hard to find. When you right-click on the desktop to change you desktop options you can only change your background. Add/Remove Programs is now Programs and Features. Why the heck did you need to change that Microsoft?
The new start menu is cool but without the search function it just isn’t usable if you have a lot of programs.
All these changes are something that I would get used to, but why should I? I like Windows XP. It works great. It’s mostly secure. Efficient on resources. Easy to use. That coming to mind I searched for a way to change Vista to look like XP. You can’t. You can change it to look like Windows 95 but not XP. Why would you do that Microsoft? Some of us liked XP, you know.
Anyways, in my adventures to upgrade to Vista, I’ve been scared off. In fact, I’d much rather change to Ubuntu. And it’s free.
If I buy another computer, it will be a Mac. Sorry Microsoft. Vista. Sucks.